TOTEM AND TABOO REVISITED: awful and fertile rise of new SUPERSTITIONS

23 aprile 2008 / April 23 2008


 
Internal index of this file:

#inizio-sito, #spiegazione, presentation, #against motherhood, #science and superstition, #totem-taboo, #sexual mutilations#macabre.tale, #amniocentesis(*), #sleeping position, #to receive, #prone, #successful trial, #stop practice
(*) continually to be up-graded / con recenti importantissimi dati

Setticismo? Incredulità? Non saranno forse altre forme di autentiche SUPERSTIZIONI??
Scepticism? Disbelief? Are they "science" or facets of another SUPERSTITION?


Motore di Ricerca interno al sito / Site's Search Engine

 
Avviso importante riguardante l'utilizzo del sito / To a better use of the site:
Questo sito e i libri che ne derivano NON sono di INFORMAZIONE, ma si costituiscono come una specie di ENCICLOPEDIE TEMATICHE, in cui vengono presentati e discussi vari argomenti da leggersi e soprattutto da CONSULTARE di volta in volta.
A seguito di difficoltà lamentate e relative richieste, l'architettura stessa del sito è stata modificata in funzione di un più agevole orientamento: sdoppiato il file/home si divide ora in secondo file con un nuovo nome - Dove cominciare / Where to begin - che riinvia a un differente URL mentre diventa iniziale e fondamentale come file semplificato dove a prima vista compaioni i links indirizzanti sui capitoli interni. Assecondando critiche e richieste man mano vengono aggiunti nuovi o rinnovati files a cui fare riferimento per informarsi su come è stata aggiornata la serie delle correzioni e nuove informazioni. Si consiglia di iniziare dal file AGGIORNAMENTI E INDICI preposto agli aggiornamenti e di precisazione dei dati "normativi" e di "diffida" o più veloce Modificazioni e novità/. Per il libro e gli indici illustrati  del libro e del sito vedi soprattutto: Dove cominciare / Where to begin.

This site and the book do NOT be a fount of notices but an ENCYCLOPEDIC gather of different subjects: one another to be read time by time, or better to be CONSULTED even for learning.
And so this Web site will always be maintained under speedy and diligently revised construction: it is suitable to begin by the file AGGIORNAMENTI E INDICI for up-dates and disclaimers - more easy: English Up-dates,
For book and illustrated indexes: Libro / Book, PAGINE FUORI TESTO INTRODUTTIVE. To general founding information go at Dove cominciare / Where to begin
L'intero sito è ora pubblicato in un libro enciclopedico - pur privo degli ultimi aggiornamenti -: per copertina, frontespizio e ulteriori spiegazioni vedi file Libro/book. The complete site - even if already at present lacking of the newest up-dates - is ready also as an Encyclopedic book
 It's Abuse NOT Science Fiction
(Per acquisti on-line / for on-line sale librerie italiane or Ibs.
INTERNATIONAL INFORMATION and orders:
 thierry@cortinalibri.it and/or ordini@cortinalibri.it)
It's Abuse NOT Science Fiction?
draft of the book cover by Andrzej (Andrew) SudaQuesta rielaborazione del famoso Sonno della ragione di Goyaufficialmente copyright - è resa molto più inquietante dell'originale per essere utilizzata come copertina del libro e spiegata dal Disegnatore Andrzej (Andrew) Suda/ This powerful, more puzzling creative modification of the Goya's Sleep of reason - marked by the official Copyright - here is used as book cover's image,  and explained by the Designer: Andrzej (Andrew) Suda:
should look just like many of the events described by the victims: they  exist, are bothersome, and we don’t know exactly WHY they  are there but they are there [come molti dei fatti descritti dalle vittime: essi esistono, turbano e noi non riusciamo a conoscere esattamente il  PERCHE' ci siano, ma ci sono.]
About the Book This book not only documents the case of Andrzej Suda, it is also filled with documentation from the worlds most influential documented cases of psychological abuse, electronic harassment, organized stalking and mind control. Some cases include Rauni Leena Kilde MD., Dr. Reinhard Munzert, Kathy Sullivan, David Larson, and many others... Please support the truth with the purchase of our book. This will document many technologies and mind control weapons that have been kept hidden from the mainstream public. Over 600 pages of action packed TRUTH!

Spiegazione

Questo file/capitolo è - quasi - interamente in Inglese in quanto costituito dall'aver unito insieme due successivi interventi a Congressi internazionali di Antropologia, e dai loro ampliamenti, relative discussioni e aggiornamenti. Benché del tutto in Inglese questo file/capitolo si trova fra le Pagine"ospitate" italiane come discordante conclusione della Parte quinta ad esse dedicata. Questa contraddizione non è casuale: è dovuta alla scelta di convalidare molti degli assunti di questo sito/libro con i contenuti originali di Posters (TOTEM AND TABOO REVISITED. WE  COULD  HAVE WATCHED AT A NEW SUPERSTITION'S BIRTH e BABIES' SLEEPING POSITION) presentati a Congressi Internazionali di Antropologia, e completati da argomenti ricavati da più approfondite bibliografie e dalle discussioni e precisazioni intercorse durante i Congressi stessi.
Come questo, altri files/capitoli si trovano anche in un altro sito Web Bambini di ieri=adulti di oggi. Adulti di oggi->adulti di domani e nel libro  - in inglese - che ne deriva From children of YESTERDAY to  adults of TOMORROW
Solo in apparenza gli argomenti trattati nei due siti - questo sugli "abusi" e quello sullo "sviluppo infantile" - sembrano privi di nesso comune, ed invece si tratta in fondo di un insieme di dati coerenti fra di loro , nella sostanza ed ancor più nei propositi e prospettive. Per maggiori informazioni e delucidazioni converrebbe quindi completare la lettura del presente sito Web/libro con una non distratta lettura di questi altri siti e libri  - sia per la parte in italiano sia per  quella in inglese - , non uguali fra di loro e completantesi a vicenda.

Presentation /presentazione

In the web page and connected book Bambini di ieri = adulti di oggi. Adulti di oggi -> adulti di domani there is a corresponding but not mirroring Italian file (and chapter) Imbroglio è il contrario di sviluppo [= To "embroil / mislead" also even "fraud" notes the contrary of to "develop"]. The content of these pages are very different from each other but notwithstanding complementary together: completing and confirming the main purposes of the whole works, sites and books they both share indirectly similar intents although using different subjects and quotations; both are sharing their strong message, with an assortment of data and concepts, checking straight or only alluding, to a rather pessimistic review of human weakness DUPED by stupidity and/or by human wickedness. Both of them have one side that prevails as it is more demonstrative: in this file/chapter the sleeping position is explained more in depth for its absolute stupidity and uselessness, nearing danger, and possibly even causing death. Imbroglio / sviluppo embodies an Italian pun not easy translated; moreover the whole file/chapter aroused from an Italian controversy regarding far-reaching - although: personal - discussion. Thus it should be enlightening to read both web sites, files, books and chapters to better consider their matching denunciation, evidenced from different sides: in many way, strengthened with many quotations, they both deplore human proneness to be DUPED and intimidated instead of being wise and perceptive; they both denounce the commonplace proclivity to prefer as a rule to be deceived and narrowed instead of to choose knowledge, thriving, development. The titles by themselves in sum up introduce a survey of the contrary of a thriving "development / evolution", of triumphant embroils, misleadings, 
ignorance, fear of the unknown, trust in magic or chance, or a false conception of causation
They emphasize the proneness of mankind to be duped and to "develop" and "breed" incoherent superstitions: however so crucial topics are displayed also in the Consciousness and memory file/chapter (as well in the Italian one Consapevolezza e memoria) where they are also further explained by a different assortment of quotations. But another file should be considered strictly connected with them: as doumentation should be straight pointed out the recently improved file/chapter Delgado & Skinner being its true, broadening and explicative extension.

SUPERSTITION 2 entries found for superstition. Main Entry: su·per·sti·tion.Pronunciation: "sü-p&r-'sti-sh&n Function: noun Etymology: Middle English supersticion, from Middle French, from Latin superstition-, superstitio, from superstit-, superstes standing over (as witness or survivor), from super- + stare to stand --  1 a : a belief or practice resulting from  superstit-, superstes standing over (as witness or survivor), from super- + stare to stand --  1 a : a belief or practice resultingfrom ignorance, fear of the unknown, trust in magic or chance, or a false conception of causation
b : anirrational abject attitude of mindtoward the supernatural, nature, or God resulting from superstition
2 : a notion maintained despite evidenceto the contrary
DUPE 3 entries found for dupe
1 dupe Pronunciation: 'düp also 'dyüp Function: noun Etymology: French, from Middle French duppe, probably alteration of huppe hoopoe: one that is easily deceived or cheated: FOOL
2 dupe Function: transitive verb Inflected Form(s): duped; dup·ing: to make a dupe of - dup·er noun synonyms DUPE, GULL, TRICK, HOAX mean todeceive by underhanded means. DUPE suggests unwariness in the person deluded. GULL stresses credulousness or readiness to be imposed on (as through greed) on the part of the victim. TRICK implies an intent to delude by means of a ruse or fraud but does not always imply a vicious intent. HOAX implies the contriving of an elaborate or adroit imposture in order to deceive. 
3  dupe  Function: noun or verb: DUPLICATE
Duplicate?
[Each personality may alternately inhabit the person's conscious awareness to the exclusion of the others,but one is usually dominant. The various personalities typically differ from one another in outlook, temperament, and body language and give themselves different first names. The condition is generally viewed as resulting from dissociative mental processes—that is, the splitting off from conscious awareness and control of thoughts, feelings, memories, and other mental components in response to situations that are painful, disturbing, or somehow unacceptable to the person experiencing them. Treatment is aimed at integrating the disparate personalities back into a single and unified personality...]
Why are mind-controlled agents, spies, couriers, assassins, better than conscious,
salaried agents/spies?

Human Pleasure Evoked by ESB (Electrical Stimulation of the Brain)

(Also an outraging, resentful file against Huxley's book Brave new world is endorsed into the below quoted site moreover against its search and crave to warn the "sacrifice" of  motherhood, home, family, freedom, even love in the name of an "universal [artificial] happiness": BRAVE NEW WORLD? A Defence Of Paradise-Engineering (look below some quotes of it)

Brave New World (1932) is one of the most bewitching andinsidious works of literature ever written. An exaggeration? Tragically, no. Brave New World has come to serve as the false symbol for any regime of universal happiness. For sure, Huxley was writing a satirical piece of fiction, notscientific prophecy. Hence to treat his masterpiece as ill-conceived futurology rather than a work of great literature might seem to miss the point. Yet the knee-jerk response of It's Brave New World! to any blueprint for chemically-driven happiness has delayed research into paradise-engineering for all sentient life. So how does Huxley turn a future where we're all notionally happy into the archetypal dystopia? If it's technically feasible, what's wrong with using biotechnology to get rid of mental pain altogether?Brave New World is an unsettling, loveless and even sinister place. This is because Huxley endows his "ideal" society with features calculated to alienate his audience. Typically, reading BNW elicits the very same disturbing feelings in the reader which the society it depicts has notionally vanquished - not a sense of joyful anticipation....Worse, it is suggested that the price of universal happiness will be the sacrifice of the most hallowed shibboleths of our culture: "motherhood", "home", "family", "freedom", even "love". The exchange yields an insipid happiness that's unworthy of the name.Its evocation arouses our unease and distaste....
It is however revealing and should be read the whole page from which came the above excerpt.

(Besides it is instead in sum up encouraging to catch a glimpse on a flankin side of Huxley's tought outlined by his wife - Laura Archera - and by her work in favour of a - from the very beginning - loved and really cared childhood.)

Against Maternal Instinct.

IT IS REALLY HORRIFYING WHAT THEY HAVE DONE IN THEIR STUDIES OF THE MATERNAL INSTINCT. JOSE DELGADO WAS INVOLVED IN THIS RESEARCH.

Milgram in inglese ..it is suggested that the price of universal happiness will be the sacrifice of the most hallowed shibboleths of our culture: MOTHERHOOD, HOME, FAMILY, FREEDOM, even LOVE. The exchange yields an insipid happiness that's unworthy of the name. Its evocation arouses our unease and distaste. 
Delgado Index
 Jose Delgado's: Physical Control of the Mind 
Chapter 16: Inhibitory Effects in Animals and Man Figure 25 (Page 173)

Above, maternal behavior is tenderly expressed by both mother monkeys, Rose and Olga, who hug, groom, and nurse their babies, Roo and Ole.
Below, radio stimulation of Rose for ten seconds in the mesencephalon evoked a rage response expressed by self-biting and abandoning her baby, Roo. For the next ten minutes Rose has lost all her maternal interest (above), ignoring the appealing calls of Roo who seeks refuge with the other mother. Below, Rose is sucking her foot and still ignoring her  baby.

Science and Supersition

pagina di proprietà dell'Associazione

I swear  by Apollo the physician, and Æsculapius, and Hygeia, and Panaceia, and all the gods and goddesses, that according to my ability and judgment, I will keep this oath and its stipulations -- to reckon him who taught me this art equally dear to me as my parents, to share my substance with him, and to relieve his necessities if required; to look upon his offspring in the same footing as my own brothers, and to teach them this art if they shall wish to learn it, without fee or stipulation, and that by precept, lecture, and every other mode of instruction, I will impart aknowledge of the art to my own sons, and those of my teachers, and to disciples bound by astipulation and oath according to the law  of medicine, but to none other. I will follow that system of regimen which, according to my ability and judgment, I consider for the benefit of my patients,  and abstain from whatever is deleterious and mischievous.  I will give no deadly  medicine to anyone if asked, nor suggest any such counsel; and in like manner I will not give to a woman a pessary to produce abortion. With purity and holiness I will pass my life and practice my art. I will not cut persons laboring under the stone, but will leave this to be done by men who are practitioners of this work. Into whatever houses I enter, I will go into them for the benefit of the sick, and will abstain from every voluntary act of mischief and corruption; and, further, from the seduction of females or males, of freemen and slaves. Whatever, in connection with my professional practice, or not in connection with it, I see or hear, in the life of men, which ought not to be spoken of abroad, I will not divulge, as reckoning that all such should be kept secret. While I continue to keep this Oath unviolated, may it be granted to me to enjoy life and the practice of this art, respected by all men, in all time. But should I trespass and violate this Oath, may the reverse be my lot. (From M.A. in Health Care Ethics).

(460??-377? BC). The first name in the history of medicine is Hippocrates, a physician from the island of Cos in ancient Greece. Known as the “Father of Medicine” Hippocrates has long been associated with the Hippocratic Oath, a body of manuscripts, which sets forth the obligations, ideals, and ethics of physicians. This ethical code is adopted as a guide to conduct by the medical profession through out the ages and still used in the graduation ceremonies of many medical schools.
FreudTOTEM AND TABOO
 
RELIGION: Main Entry: re·li·gion Pronunciation: ri-'li-j&n Function: noun
Etymology: Middle English religioun, from Latin religion-, religio supernatural constraint, sanction, religious practice, perhaps from religare to restrain, tie back -- more at RELY
1 a : the state of a religious <a nun in her 20th year of religion> 
 b (1) : the service and worship of God or the supernatural 
 b (2) : commitment or devotion to religious faith or observance
2 : a personal set or institutionalized system of religious attitudes, beliefs, and practices
3 archaic : scrupulous conformity : CONSCIENTIOUSNESS
4 : a cause, principle, or system of beliefs held to with ardor and faith
TRADITION: Main Entry: tra·di·tion Pronunciation: tr&-'di-sh&n Function: noun
Etymology: Middle English tradicioun, from Middle French & Latin; Middle French tradition, from Latin tradition-, traditio action of handing over, tradition -- more at TREASON
1 : an inherited, established, or customary pattern of thought, action, or behavior (as a religious practice or  a social custom)
2 : the handing down of information, beliefs, and customs by word of mouth or by example from one generation to another without written instruction
3 : cultural continuity in social attitudes, customs, and institutions
4 : characteristic manner, method, or style - tra·di·tion·al  /-'dish-n&l, -'di-sh&-n&l/ adjective
- tra·di·tion·al·ly adverb
MYTH: Main Entry: myth Pronunciation: 'mith Function: noun Etymology: Greek mythos
1 a : a usually traditional story of ostensibly historical events that serves to unfold part of the world view of a people or explain a practice, belief, or natural phenomenon 
1 b : PARABLE, ALLEGORY
2 a : a popular belief or tradition that has grown up around something or someone; especially : one embodying the ideals and institutions of a society or segment of society <seduced by the American myth of individualism -- Orde Coombs> 
2 b : an unfounded or false notion
3 : a person or thing having only an imaginary or unverifiable existence
4 : the whole body of myths
FAITH: Main Entry: 1 faith  Pronunciation: 'fAth Function: noun Inflected Form(s): plural faiths  /'fAths, sometimes 'fA[th]z/ Etymology: Middle English feith, from Old French feid, foi, from Latin fides; akin to Latin fidere to trust -- more at BIDE
1 a : allegiance to duty or a person : LOYALTY 
1 b (1) : fidelity to one's promises 
1 b (2) : sincerity of intentions
2 a (1) : belief and trust in and loyalty to God 
2 a (2) : belief in the traditional doctrines of a religion
2 b (1) : firm belief in something for which there is no proof
2 (2) : complete trust
3 : something that is believed especially with strong conviction; especially : a system of religious beliefs synonym see BELIEF
- in faith : without doubt or question : VERILY
FANATIC: Main Entry: fa·nat·ic Pronunciation: f&-'na-tik Variant(s): or fa·nat·i·cal  /-ti-k&l/ Function: adjective Etymology: Latin fanaticus inspired by a deity, frenzied, from fanum temple -- more at FEAST: 
marked by excessive enthusiasm and often intense uncritical devotion <they're fanatic about politics> - fanatic noun - fa·nat·i·cal·ly  /f&-'na-ti-k(&-)lE/ adverb - fa·nat·i·cal·ness  /-k&l-n&s/ noun.
TABOO: Main Entry: 1 ta·boo Variant(s): also ta·bu  /t&-'bü, ta-/ Function: adjective Etymology: Tongan tabu
1 : forbidden to profane use or contact because of what are held to be dangerous supernatural powers
2 a : banned on grounds of morality or taste <the subject is taboo> 
2 b : banned as constituting a risk
Main Entry: 2 taboo Variant(s): also tabu Function: noun Inflected Form(s): plural taboos also tabus
1 : a prohibition against touching, saying, or doing something for fear of immediate harm from a supernatural force
2 : a prohibition imposed by social custom or as a protective measure
3 : belief in taboos
TOTEM: Main Entry: to·tem Pronunciation: 'tO-t&m Function: noun Etymology: Ojibwa oto.te.man his totem
1 a : an object (as an animal or plant) serving as the emblem of a family or clan and often as a reminder of its ancestry; also : a usually carved or painted representation of such an object 
1 b : a family or clan identified by a common totemic object
2 : something that serves as an emblem or revered symbol

And then: so why nobody stopped just in time dangerously bizarre occurrences?

Scientific definition of “trial” The Clinical Trials and Informatics Support team provides  statistical and data processing support for all multicentre and some single-centre research projects undertaken by the Programme, as well as technical advice on the design, management, analysis and interpretation of research projects.
TRIAL: Main Entry: 1tri·al Pronunciation: 'trI(-&)l Function: noun Etymology: Anglo-French, from trier to trial
1 a : the action or process of trying or putting to the proof: TEST
1 b : a preliminary contest (as in a sport)
2 : the formal examination before a competent  tribunal of the matter in issue in a civil or criminal cause in order to determine such issue 
3 : a test of faith, patience, or stamina through subjection to suffering or temptation; broadly : a source of vexation or annoyance 
4 a : a try out or experiment to test quality, value, or usefulness 
4 b : one of a number of repetitions of an experiment
5 : ATTEMPT
Tested by self-centered “trials”, claimed as revolutionary certainties, most of the so considered scientific theories are sometimes only introductory, too often self-confirming, “hypothesis”. But, so supported by deceitful trials, mindless "fashions" arouse, passing off as unquestionable - even if after becoming transient - new evidence based discoveries. Thus professionals themselves, intimidated or worshipping their “Masters” even in good faith, forget their skill and mind and - in turn: convinced "brain-washed" - propose these "discoveries" to their clients. Scared and frail “good parents” circularly choose and support the most narrow and rigid doctors who can correspond to their searching a "reassuring" aid. In spite of every real consequence, together doctors and clients, are gratified to put into practice dogmatic "finding" praised as assured "theory". It was told in a professional mailing list that ... doesn’t exist any obligation to give up normal instincts: the parents are free, I repeat FREE, to end every time the experimentation, moreover since in U.S. exists a  strong and strict IRB (Institutional Review Board) - established in 1991 as an independent review board that provides protection for human subjects through the initial and ongoing review of research studies, ensure that research subjects are appropriately informed about the risks and benefits of participating in a research study.
Doctor News
Doctor News
Doctor news

Epidemiologo, studi sbagliati al 50 p
er cento
La verita' scientifica? Forse non esiste. Le conclusioni raggiunte dalla maggior parte degli studi potrebbero essere sbagliate. Pescando a caso un qualunque lavoro tra quelli pubblicati in letteratura, la probabilita' che concluda il giusto sono inferiori al 50%. A disilludere ricercatori, medici e opinione pubblica sull'affidabilità degli studi scientifici e' l'epidemiologo John Ioannidis, della Scuola di Medicina dell'universita' di Ioannina, in Grecia. In un articolo sulla rivista 'Plos Medicine', l'esperto chiama in causa non solo l'errore umano, ma anche e soprattutto problemi sperimentali e statistici. Limiti il piu' delle volte insuperabili, che inevitabilmente finiscono per compromettere la correttezza dei risultati ottenuti. Secondo Ioannidis, i piu' a rischio di arrivare a conclusioni sbagliate sarebbero gli studi molto piccoli, quelli 'disegnati' male e quelli che producono risultati numerici bassi (il caso, per esempio, di un farmaco efficace solo nel 10% dei pazienti).
Ma lo specialista invita a 'prendere con le pinze' anche i dati degli studi di dimensioni piu' vaste, di quelli ben disegnati e di quelli che lavorano su argomenti particolarmente 'caldi', relativamente ai quali i ricercatori sentono maggiori 'pressioni'. 'Dovremmo accettare il fatto che la maggior parte delle ricerche verra' confutata. Alcune saranno ripetute e confermate', aggiunge Ioannidis, sottolineando che, almeno in campo scientifico, 'replicare un dato ha piu' valore di scoprirlo per la prima volta''. L'esperto avanza dei dubbi sulla correttezza dell'espressione ''statisticamente significativo', ben nota ai lettori di studi scientifici. ''Comunemente - ricorda - un dato viene considerato 'statisticamente significativo' quando esiste solo una probabilita' su 20 che sia unicamente frutto del caso'. Ma questo metodo di calcolo non da' sufficienti garanzie, ''specialmente quando, per esempio, si tratta di collegare una certa malattia al gene che potrebbe esserne il responsabile''.
Molte certezze potrebbero dunque crollare? A rassicurare uomini di laboratorio, clinici e pazienti e' Solomon Snyder, senior editor di 'Pnas' ed esperto di neuroscienze alla Johns Hopkins Medical School di Baltimora, Usa. Quando leggo la letteratura scientifica - osserva l'esperto su 'New Scientist' online - non penso certo di trovarmi di fronte a un manuale'. Non c'e' la pretesa di trovare 'la risposta', bensi' 'il desiderio di ottenere nuove idee'.
So why nobody stopped just in time such dangerously bizarre occurrences?
Scientific definition of “trial” The Clinical Trials and Informatics Support team provides  statistical and data processing support for all multicentre and some single-centre research projects undertaken by the Programme, as well as technical advice on the design, management, analysis and interpretation of research projects.

TRIAL: Main Entry: 1tri·al Pronunciation: 'trI(-&)l Function: noun Etymology: Anglo-French, from trier to trial
1 a : the action or process of trying or putting to the proof: TEST
1 b : a preliminary contest (as in a sport)
2 : the formal examination before a competent  tribunal of the matter in issue in a civil or criminal cause in order to determine such issue 
3 : a test of faith, patience, or stamina through subjection to suffering or temptation; broadly : a source of vexation or annoyance 
4 a : a try out or experiment to test quality, value, or usefulness 
4 b : one of a number of repetitions of an experiment
5 : ATTEMPT
FASHION: synonyms FASHION, STYLE, MODE, VOGUE, FAD, RAGE, CRAZE mean the usage accepted by those who want to be up-to-date.
FASHION is the most general term and applies to any way of dressing, behaving, writing, or performing that is favored at any one time or place <the current fashion>.
STYLE often implies a distinctive fashion adopted by people of taste <a media baron used to traveling in style>.
MODE suggests the fashion of the moment among those anxious to appear elegant and sophisticated <slim bodies are the mode at this resort>.
VOGUE stresses the wide acceptance of a fashion <short skirts are back in vogue>.
FAD suggests caprice in taking up or in dropping a fashion <last year's fad is over>.
RAGE and CRAZE stress intense enthusiasm in adopting a fad <Cajun food was the rage nearly everywhere for a time> <crossword puzzles once seemed just a passing craze but have lasted>. 
synonym see in addition METHOD

TOTEM AND TABOO rvisited, we could have watched at a new SUPERSTITION'S birth.

congresso Firenze
Anthropology Congress Poster

When, unlike a yogi, we do not choose our trances, and we are unaware of the types and nature of the pathological trances in our lives, then there are things we are unaware of. What we are unaware of causes more human suffering than the sometimes painful knowledge of the truth. One goal of a robust and magical life is to be as aware as possible of our options. When our unconscious pathological trances cripple our options the result is often disaster and tragedy in our personal lives, our society and in the environment. (From:Trance as a Tool)
What we are unaware of, causes more human suffering than the sometimes painful knowledge of the truth…:  this consideration pertains either to negative re-living past memories or to almost umbearable present difficulties. But in the meantime what knowledge, what truth? People have to keep in view that - unreasonably - more human sufferings often arouse from the incapability to envisage the really impossible foresight of what will happen in the time to come: as is of course the knowledge of an unforeseen good or a painful mischance, or even only from the constant will to throw away unaccepted EMOTIONS. And thus, after having lost the truth, having dissociated themselves from the reality, mindlessly hinting at a global improvement, dimly warning against imaginary threatens and damages...: all this regards NOT only homogeneous, self-restrincting groups, but also cultured people goes on without any obstacle in a similar banalizing and undemonstrative way. A recent book - The Neuroscience of Psychotherapy Building and Rebuilding the Human Brain (by Louis Cozolino) - presents its theories as very promising but with a double-edged meaning, also to be "used" in a double-edged way: as this can explain the possibility to heal even persons who suffered terrible past mishaps, so this can suggest also that the "superstitions' proneness" of humankind's nature can rather easily get too many people brain-washed almost before having realized to hold their own minds.
It seems logical to believe that human beings can follow traditions, or trust on Religions (plural), or are “reason supporters”, or  even - at least in the wealthy world - are pleased to play on changing customs and to promote new FASHIONS, forgetting suddenly the previous ones. Religions could become dogmatic, devotees can behave as fanatics…, but also in the Western affluent and rational world sometimes for some unexpected facts a fashion becomes instead a MYTH, a SUPERSTITION: it is to say something unconscious, utterly dissociated from the real mind, and absolutely more gluing than Religious believing. In the case of health or of children rearing the FUTURE can give great grants and suddenly take them away, can give awful sorrows and effective precautions, but - what is often a worse danger - gets not only a lot of expecting and/or fearful emotions, but to avoid them a lot of … stupid countermeasures.
Spontaneously (or more often fraudulently promoted) static and temporary "novelties" become fashionable. This fashion however is no longer ephemeral, but develops into FAITH and is flaunted and accepted without criticism as "the best". It is defended by conservative borders in every situation and results in absurd obedience - if not longing - to absurd and not fitting drug’s prescriptions and dosages... (Here it should be said as an example a crucial assignment very broadly forewarn in space and time, a "duty" concerning a basic side of rearing babies: Feed babies only EVERY four hours... is one of typical decrees: so often producing in fact harmful consequences;  but the real grammar set up of such an absurdity was found in a fanciful misunderstanding of the real text proposed - to can be reached in a little, from 1920s years magazine, by O.N.M.I. (Italian National Organization for Motherhood and Childhood): where was written Working women must feed their babies AT  LEAST, [not LESS THAN!], every FOUR hours: without no delay.
Not delayed mixed-up with not less than...: how is it possible that every similar banalizing and undemonstrative idea so validates or confirms itself in self-ingrained circles more often vicious?
Besides: could regard only homogeneous, self-restrincting groups these hinting at a global - bogus - improvement? could this to be guided by - forged - alarms regard only simple if not moronic lay-persons? On the contrary not: everyone can see how everywhere these, even long terms and broad expanded, real superstitions develop into a faith; how do they become transformed into a glue which nobody and nothing can remove: not reason, not feelings, not results, even not - at least finally proclaimed - strong warnings of death danger (as for example the new-born position face down). And - what is more strange - nobody censures and/or rejects them: neither concerned (even if damaged) persons themselves, nor children's parents nor even professionals.

So, often with inconsistent reason, whichever impromptu sharing a "neurotic concern" can become widespread; but also whoever "tricky arrogant" can enter in this so open pathway towards an indirect mind-control. Imposed as a new Totem, every bogus fear thus at first menaces proclaiming - hypothetic - forthcoming damages, and then offers pseudo-guarantees if the "mind-controlled" people follows so established hoaxes or even so accepted swindles.

copyright Pucci Violi
Copyright Pucci Violi

Fear“ believes to keeps safe on building barricades, and then: narrows spaces, knowledge, relationship and understanding.
On return again and again it widens new fearfulness On return again and again it widens new fearfulness and more and more intrusive dependency: who is easily deceived or cheated: FOOL
Neurosis absorbs anguish as a sponge. It is convenient, it gets as a mighty mummy...

Neurosis is a personal, intimate disorder which affect private freedom and impairs individual concentration and attention; but - as told in this Italian writing - it gets as a sponge helping to absorb anguish... - even if neurosis itself could be a  personal ailment it is more significant since affects a great deal of people: and then, when collective, this lessened existence could become everywhere a fertile ground fitting to foster superstitions.
(Taboos are duping prohibitions, but also compelling order - with even more RAGE and CRAZE.)

Nevrosi

Thus, doctors’ words are acquired by fearful parents as guarantees against all life’s risks (look instead the main Ippocrates statement: Momentary occurs life, deceptive is knowledge, demanding is discernment; but doctors’ words in turn arise from their teachers’ words passed so often off evidence based realities, mistaking doubtful and self-confirming trials, testing at random more or less casual bizarre ideas. All the time vicious circles renew themselves, and gullible people doesn't notice that too often so-believed “theories” are changeable: and so personal behavior have not to deal with actual truth but only with up-dating “fashions”. As a matter of fact the parents’ weakness and stubborn lack of self-confidence, can be directed in every - also difficult, illogical, even dangerous - direction: it sets to prescribe fixed behaviors on the times, tied even if told "advanced", compelling even if told “permissive”.
Maternal instinct?
Static, temporary “novelties”, ephemeral changing fashions are proclaimed and complied without any criticism for the time being as “the best” - till new arrival -. So it is misleading to set stereotyped appraisals as: old styled families are ideal and perfect, with their typically good fathers and mothers, as during the good old times; but it is as much as incorrect to state that the "new" is  a sure progressive improvement. Modern families and modern way at rearing children? Assured with and more and more reliable systems for children's sake? Up-to-date knowledge and more broadly shared information?

MATERNAL INSTINCT? WORLDWIDE SPREAD CURRENT EXAMPLES OF DANGEROUS CONTRARY.

IT IS REALLY HORRIFYING WHAT THEY HAVE DONE IN THEIR STUDIES OF THE MATERNAL INSTINCT.
How could such "brain-washing" methods have taken so deep-seated roots? How can a pervasive, indirect "mind-control" be so efficient? Why is it quite impossible to convince even keen persons to avoid it? Nonsensical? And then: why moreover is it so hard to stop everywhere such practices in spite of any warning against? Comparable violations can happen only in Africa and in other countries of the Third World?

Violence in the womb and at birth has always been a concern to members of APPPAH. Ironically, in modern hospital birth, violence and pain have become routine for babies. For most of the 20th century, neither obstetricians nor psychologists have regarded pain as a reality for newborns. Therefore, doctors have not hesitated to expose the baby to a harsh environment at birth, or to introduce painful routines, or painful instruments... Babies protest being jabbed with needles for blood samples and vitamin K shots, don't like to be turned upside down, rushed through space, and handled by different people. Their skin is extremely sensitive and they complain when rubbed and cleaned. We have been making them angry, afraid, defensive, sad, and confused--for the greater part of the century.
origin of violenceThe origins of circumcision are approached by studying the distribution of sexual mutilations on the map of continents and their severity among indigenous cultures. The analysis suggests that Africa is the epicenter for altering the genitalia of both males and females.Frederick Hodges, now a medical history fellow at Oxford, supplies a fascinating history of how involuntary sexual mutilation was institutionalized in the United States. What began as a cure for masturbation, and all the illnesses thought to be caused by onanism, has been lauded and subsequently dismissed as the cure for epilepsy, immoral behavior, cancer, and sexually transmitted diseases. Hodges argues, quite convincingly, that the validity of the current medical justifications do not differ much from the original justifications. He notes, "Whatever incurable disease happens to be the focus of national attention in any given time period will be the disease that circumcision advocates will use as an excuse for circumcision.
Circumcision is part of mainstream American culture, and, despite having its medical credibility essentially decimated, it continues unabated....
Sexual Mutilations: A Human Tragedy
George C. Denniston and Marilyn F. Milos (Eds.) New York: Plenum Publishing, 237 pages, 1997. ISBN=0306455897
A major portion of the book addresses the issue of female genital mutilation as currently practiced inparts of Africa. Berhane Ras-Work, the current president of the Inter-African Committee on Traditional Practices Affecting the Health of Women and Children, provides a history of the organizational attempts to end the practice of FGM in Africa. Efforts started with general statements from international organizations and are now being implemented by people in the community. Outside interference is shunned and only acts to galvanize opposition. While the prevalence of FGM in Europe is unknown, Italian investigators Amnesty International (°) presented their estimates of the number of genitally mutilated women in their country. Likewise, a representative of Germany's organization (I)NTACT spoke to how her country is responding to this practice.  [(°)Sono almeno 135 milioni, secondo l'Organizzazione Mondiale della Sanità, le ragazze e le bambine che hanno subito mutilazioni sessuali e ogni anno se ne aggiungono altri due milioni. Le MGF sono praticate soprattutto in Africa e in alcuni paesi del Medio Oriente (Egitto, Yemen Emirati Arabi). Vi sono anche casi di mutilazioni in alcune parti dell'Asia, nelle Americhe e in Europa - compresa l'Italia - all'interno delle comunità di immigrati.]

Macabre tales of medical arrogance

Maternal instinct??? Experiments on children? Induced on children artificial pregnancy???
How medicine could have succeed to induce artificial pregnancy??? But then: what will have become the babies?
little girls pregnant

no need to explain what happened to these EIGHT YEARS old little girls!!!
Their bellies showning a six monthes pregnancy? At least a very mandatory NEED to get known how horrific can become scientists's shameless power!




Maternal, parental instinct? Or: children "hired" as human guinea-pigs for atrocious, disfiguring and/or mutilating experiments?

the same child: normal and then more and more disfigured

As Nature Made Him:The Boy Who Was Raised As a Girl  by John Colapinto

...un'idea di bellezza canora durata oltre tre Secoli dalla seconda metà del Cinquecento, inizio della Controriforma, agli inizi del Novecento quando Alessandro Moreschi - the "last castrato" come lo battezzarono i pioneristici discografici inglesi venuti a registrarne la voce - era ancora attivo nella Cappella Sistina. Non fu veramente l'ultimo, abbiamo testimonianze di anziani evirati vivi fino ai Sessanta, ma dal 1903 un motu proprio Vaticano decise che non si potevano più accogliere bambini castrati per addestrarli alla professione di cantante.
(Vedi Sandro Cappelletto:
Una voce pochissimo fa (di soprato e baritono)  La Stampa giovedì 6 gennaio 2005 pag 25 "Cultura e spettacoli"
Vedi Il castrato di Simone Bartolini).

Ma se nei secoli scorsi si castravano bambini per mantenerne la voce bianca e così ottenere dei soprani "speciali"  la mutilazione  sottocitata - ...un - creduto! - e ampiamente sbandierato successo del COMPORTAMENTISMO è ancora più raccapricciante nella sua quasi "banalità" di situazione "privata", ma esemplifica bene teoria, impostazione e principi del Comportamentismo stesso.

E qui presentiamo questa storia "privata": la storia di un caso singolo, ma non per questo meno significativa di una certa cultura pseudo-scientifica, di un certo modo ufficialmente programmatico di NON-RISPETTARE la Natura e gli esseri umani.

Comment from Amazon.com
Once you begin reading As Nature Made Him, a mesmerizing story of amedicaltragedyandits traumatic results, you absolutely won't want to put it down. Following a botched circumcision, a family is convinced to raise their infant son, Bruce, as a girl. They rename the child Brenda and spend the next14 yearstrying to transform him into a her.Brenda's childhood reads as one filled with anxiety and loneliness, and her fear and confusion are present on nearly every page concerning her early childhood. Much of her pain is caused by Dr. Money, who is presented as a villainous medical man attempting to coerce an unwilling child to submit to numerous unpleasant treatments. Reading over interviews and reports of decisions made by this doctor, it's difficult to contain anger at the widespread results of his insistence that natural-born gender can be altered with little more than willpower and hormone treatments. The attempts of his parents, twin brother, and extended family to assist Brenda to be happily female are touching--the sense is overwhelmingly of a family wanting to do "right" while being terribly mislead as to what "right" is for her. As Brenda makes the decision to live life as a male (at age 14), she takes the name David and begins the process of reversing the effects of estrogen treatments. David's ultimate successful life--a solid marriage, honest and close family relationships, and his bravery in making his childhood public -- bring an uplifting end to his story. Equally fascinating is the latest segment of the longtime nature/nurture controversy, and the interviews of various psychological researchers and practitioners form a larger framework around David's struggle to live as the gender he was meant to be. -- Jill Lightner --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.


The Milgram Experiment:
A Lesson in Depravity

The Perils of Obedience -
Obedience to Authority  by Stanley Milgram


Obbedienza all'autorità. Uno sguardo sperimentale
Milgram Stanley  Editore Einaudi

Amniocentesi o eugenetica? /AMNIOCENTESIS OR EUGENICS?


Eugenetica: Hitler

Cure ai nati molto pretermine, il documento del gruppo di esperti riuniti dal Ministro Livia Turco

Sempre più i sopravvissuti all'aborto "terapeutico"?
In questo caso la decisione di interrompere la gravidanza non è la conseguenza di una pseudo-diagnosi dovuta ad amniocentesi, ma da una semplice ecografia: è però comunque un'occasione opportuna per porre severamente il problema.
DOPPIA "presa in giro": eugenetica e accanimento terapeutico.
A REDOUBLED TRICKERY: Eugenics and Therapeutic Obstinacy - over-treatment.

Proprio in data 8 marzo 2007 - Giornata in onore della Donna - una notizia, peraltro prevedibile, giunge in forma ufficiale ad esempio esposta sinteticamente in Televideo:
VIVO DOPO ABORTO, OSPEDALI:NESSUN ERRORE
Un bimbo è nato vivo durante l'interruzione di gravidanza al V mese alla quale la mamma si era sottoposta dopo che le era stato diagnosticato una grave malformazione al feto. Il piccolo è in incubatrice all'ospedale pediatrico Meyer di Firenze, in condizioni gravi. (*)
Non c'è stato alcun errore nè nella refertazione ecografica, nè nella comunicazione alla coppia hanno detto i direttori dell'azienda ospedaliera Careggi e del Dipartimento Materno infantile aggiungendo che è stata rispettata la legge 194 e la libera volontà di una donna. La regolarità della procedura adottata è stata riscontrata dalla commissione incaricata della verifica.
(Il decesso è avvenuto dopo sei giorni: in altri termini l'agonia medicalizzata è durata sei giorni.)

A poignant case of Therapeutic Abortion for - only presumed - fetal malformation: resulting instead in birth of a living immature baby; and then resulting in an appalling show of over-treatment.
The final outcome was a weekly lasting agony.
· Mother wanted procedure after fears of abnormality
· Law requires resuscitation if foetus shows signs of life
John Hooper in Rome Thursday March 8, 2007 The Guardian
A baby was struggling for life in an intensive care unit in Florence yesterday after being resuscitated following an attempted abortion at 22 weeks' gestation because of indications of abnormalities which turned out to be false. The baby's mother, who has not been identified, was admitted to hospital for a late abortion at the end of last week after being told her child might have abnormalities. The child showed signs of life after the procedure and, under Italian law, doctors were obliged to try to save it.

AMNIOCENTESIS (or... EUGENICS?): Amniocentesis is a diagnostic procedure performed by inserting a hollow needle through the abdominal wall into the uterus and withdrawing a small amount of fluid from the sac surrounding the fetus. Amniocentesis can be used to diagnose a large number of genetic and chromosomal abnormalities in the fetus. In addition, it is helpful in the diagnosis of the severity of Rh incompatibility, lung maturity, and neural tube defects (such as spina bifida). There is a slight chance of infection or injury to the fetus. There is even a smaller chance of miscarriage.(Abortion - spontaneous) This test is typically performed when a problem is suspected, so the benefits outweigh the risk.
To have amniocentesis is a surely invasive - and even expensive - harming practice for both: mother (having abdomen adhesions for ever) and child (risking to have feet, legs, genitals... damaged,  or rather: all the more, to die in miscarriage!). But moreover what is the result of this "safety-making" (???) screening? An EUGENIC  "not abortion" but induced premature birth to eliminate - perhaps still living - "not eugenic" baby!
(Still living? to eliminate or perhaps otherwise to spread a bold show of medical arrogance?
 Sport-like records to attain and challenge?
MIAMI, Florida (AP) -- A premature baby that doctors say spent less time in the womb than any other surviving infant is to be released from a Florida hospital Tuesday.
Amillia Sonja Taylor was just 9 1/2 inches long and weighed less than 10 ounces when she was born October 24. She was delivered 21 weeks and six days after conception. Full-term births come after 37 to 40 weeks.)

It is important to remember that abnormal test result cannot exclude every possible problem with the baby. Not all birth defects can be detected by these tests ... Amniocentesis usually is done in the SECOND TRIMESTER. Some medical centers offer early amniocentesis, done between 11 and 14 weeks after the last menstrual period. However, early amniocentesis is considered experimental and recent studies suggest that it is riskier than second-trimester amniocentesis...


Paradigmatiche vicende italiane:

Distrofia incurabile? Feti non-eugenetici da eliminare inesorabilmente???
DUCHENNE: NUOVI RISULTATI (12/01/07)
Sono stati pubblicati su PNAS (Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences) i risultati di una sperimentazione condotta presso i laboratori dell’Istituto Scientifico Universitario San Raffaele, dell’Università degli Studi di Milano, dell’Università di Milano-Bicocca, dell’Università di Pavia, dell’Istituto Medea e del Centro Ricerche Nicox. La ricerca ha indagato gli effetti di una nuova molecola - HCT 1026 (nitroflurbiprofene) - su due modelli animali di distrofia muscolare. I dettagli dello studio italiano: il nitroflurbiprofene, oggetto anche di altri studi per il trattamento della demenza di Alzheimer, chimicamente è un antinfiammatorio non steroideo cui è stata aggiunta la capacità di fungere da donatore di gruppi NO. Il nitrossido, deficitario nei pazienti distrofici, è fondamentale per il metabolismo e la rigenerazione dei muscoli.

O al contrario: "figli" che DEVONO nascere malgrado tutto ??? E' "egoismo parentale" o "istinto materno" da assecondare costi quello che costi ??? O invece ci troviamo di fronte a un altro subdolo aspetto dell'istinto materno da DISTRUGGERE ???

 ESPERIMENTI SU BAMBINI ??? Esperimenti preliminari in vista della
 FECONDAZIONE ASSISTITA ???

little girls pregnant


Come fosse una normale passeggiat di famiglia in riva al mare: non occorrono spiegazioni, ma soltanto far CONOSCERE ! A otto anni ed al sesto mese di gravidanza!



Altre assurdità? Gravi incongruenze? Incongruenze o persino imposture?
 Commento amaro di un fatto paradigmatico di imperante incoerenza:

Televideo 21/12/2006 12:53 WELBY, UNA VITA TRA LOTTA E SOFFERENZA
 WELBY, UNA VITA TRA LOTTA E SOFFERENZA

Si è conclusa la lunga sofferenza di Piergiorgio Welby. Nato a Roma nel 1945, era stato colpito dalla distrofia muscolare progressiva quando aveva 20 anni. Dal 1997,la sua sopravvivenza era assicurata da un respiratore automatico.
Welby, nel settembre scorso lacia un appello al presidente Napolitano chiedendo di poter morire con dignità. Sul caso si accende un dibattito che divide le coscienze.Intanto si rivolge la Tribunale di Roma per ottenere l'interruzione delle cure,ma il ricorso è ritenuto inammissibile. Di ieri,infine,il parere del Consiglio Superiore di Sanità che non ha ritenuto accanimento terapeutico le cure che lo tenevano in vita.

Se negli anni in cui era nato Welby - e così pure Tullio Regge - ci fosse stata la possibilità diagnostica dell'amniocentesi, questi due casi di DISTROFIA MUSCOLARE sarebbero stati NON abortiti ma uccisi in quanto l'eliminazione tardiva di un feto potenzialmente VITALE non è propriamente la stessa cosa dell'aborto di un embrione.
E su questo tema NESSUNO ufficialmente - e neanche la Chiesa - ha qualcosa da ridire: anzi questa manovra cruenta di diagnostica altamente invasiva  - nonché costosa e sempre con sequele per entrambi mamma e bambino - il cui UNICO scopo è quello EUGENETICO o EUTANASICO (!) viene ampiamente caldeggiata con metodi di subdola ... "sobillazione", inneggianti ad una superstiziosa pseudo-fiducia, per lo più viene creduta una manovra "protettiva come fosse una .... vaccinazione.

What to say for an Italian occurrence regarding the forbidden possibility to stop unbearable extreme medical cares - artificial respiratory implement - to a sixty years old person ailing for MUSCULAR DYSTROPHY: just for one of the - few - congenital illnesses "avoided" - or better to be "killed" - applying the ill-timed miscarriage "required" by the amniocentesis' report?
Italian Poet Dies With Help From a Doctor By IAN FISHER Published: December 22, 2006
With the legal fight to be allowed to end his own life undecided, Piergiorgio Welby died Wednesday after a doctor sedated him and removed the respirator that was keeping him alive.
(Death and Dying,Medicine and Health,Doctors,Politics and Government,Italy,Rome (Italy),Roman Catholic Church,Welby) ROME, Dec. 21
Piergiorgio Welby, who had eloquently begged Italy’s leaders to let him end his life legally, died late Wednesday after a doctor sedated him and removed the respirator that had kept him alive for nine years. But Mr. Welby, 60 years old, an advocate of euthanasia who had muscular dystrophy for 40 years, died without the legal clarity he had hoped to achieve. His decision to be removed from the respirator seemed to be a final challenge, which was quickly taken up in this Roman Catholic country with a deep institutional opposition to euthanasia. Hours after his death was announced, Thursday, conservative lawmakers demanded the arrest of the doctor.

BABIES' SLEEPING POSITION / BABIES SLEEPING FACE DOWN

Another example, very milder, very simpler, apparently harmless, surely not expensive is the hint for a - strange - required unchanging sleeping babies' position: the worldwide and  long-lasting fashion (outspread for more than twenty years) to put babies face-down. The most during the '70s - '80s years almost EVERY baby had to be put - or better: ordered to be put - to sleep face down, it is to say in an unnatural, uneasy position. Apparently harmless, this compelling doctors' intimation has to be nevertheless considered critically and not as a banality; it is hence a so absurd "required" custom to give the impression to come even only from a bad joke. But since it is NOT a joke,  then: what was it? a trial? Was it a trial to reach the aim to rear blinded babies? Was rather a TRIAL to recognize how much is credulous and PRONE to suggestions to whole people worldwide?
posizione patognomonica
Vedi René Spitz: IL PRIMO ANNO  DI VITA. Studio psicanalitico sllo sviluppo delle relazioni oggettuali. Armando Editore (traduzione C.Masina e V.Volterra Capogrossi): Deprivazione emotiva parziale (depressione anaclitica). Figura 14: Posizione patognomonica. / In his book - First Year  of Life: A Psychoanalytic Study of Normal and Deviant Development of Object Relations René Spitz considered this position typical of the anaclitic depression when he applied this term to the behavior of infants separated from "good" mothers for extended periods of time in hospital. After three months of separation from mother displays of distress in the infants studied would be replaced by vacant unresponsiveness.

PRONE POSITION to be imposed
? The endeavor to keep in view this fact is twofold:
  1. a description, an anthropological and even ergonomic description, concerning one, this strange one, of the various ways how to manage babies’ sleep: the why and how and exactly when and by whom this strange idea could arise and become so worldwide spread. To lie prone? However this enough already warning situation displays another more “absurd” fact,  a new more weird query arousing from: how is it possible that a quite new, not traditional at all, an even strange custom as “face-down babies”, could become an ineffaceable myth, something as a ruthless superstition?
  2. But here it should be added another consideration and example, regarding how all facts can be chained beyond the times, encircling generations and - true or artificial - knowledge. An Anthropologist - i.e. a scientist not a whoever commonplace uninformed person - said that he would have been compliant to doctor’s prescription.
  3.  Instead a doctor considered - at least - APPALLING such assertion, and answered that a liable doctor should NEVER  take the responsibility (and so: culpability) to instigate some one to do something doubtful for <